Skip to main content

02 May, 2014

Marine Protected Areas consultation results published

The results of a public consultation on a proposed network of Marine Protected Areas (MPAs) have been published today (Friday 2 May), along with scientific advice and recommendations

The Scottish Government has national and international commitments to establish a network of nature conservation MPAs in its seas. The MPA proposals formed part of a 16-week Planning Scotland's Seas' consultation last year, which also sought views on a list of Priority Marine Features, a National Marine Plan and marine renewable energy plans.

Marine Scotland has today published its analysis of the consultation. This shows that of the 14,703 respondents, only 12 (twelve) answered No', when asked if they were in favour of a Scottish network of Nature Conservation MPAs.

Also published today is scientific advice to Ministers from Scottish Natural Heritage (SNH) and the Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC). SNH is recommending 17 MPAs in territorial waters (within 12nm of the coast) and JNCC recommends a further 16 MPAs in offshore waters.

Together with existing EU designations, such as Special Protection Areas (SPAs) and Special Areas of Conservation (SACs) with marine elements, these could form Scotland's MPA network.

Marine Scotland coordinated 56 public events during the consultation, at coastal venues around the country, 36 of which were supported by SNH staff. These included a number of SNH-led MPA drop-in sessions giving people a chance to hear what is being proposed and to ask questions.

Environment Secretary Richard Lochhead said:

"Today we published the independent analysis of the consultation responses we received to Planning Scotland's Seas.' I am delighted we received so many responses which shows how passionate people in Scotland are about our beautiful marine environment.

"This government has worked hard to introduce marine planning and the upcoming National Marine Plan will help achieve the balance needed for sustainable growth. We will also be able to confirm the locations of the Marine Protected Areas later this year. I would like to thank SNH and JNCC for the progress made so far."

The majority of responses to the MPA part of the consultation were generated by campaigns related to seabirds, whales and dolphins, or community campaigns in support of proposals, such as the South Arran proposed MPA and progression of an MPA between Skye and Mull.

Following an initial review, Marine Scotland asked SNH and JNCC to consider scientific and evidence issues raised in the responses.

Ron Macdonald, SNH director of policy and advice, said:

"Our advice published today is the result of careful consideration of the MPA consultation responses. Our report focuses on the scientific aspects of 137 responses from individuals and organisations about the 17 MPAs proposed in territorial waters. We have advised Scottish Ministers that all of the 17 inshore possible MPAs merit designation.

"With three metres of coastline for every person in Scotland our seas are an environmental, economic and recreational resource that makes an enormous contribution to our quality of life. The huge response to the consultation on MPAs covered a range of views on the challenges of balancing environmental interests with other uses of the sea. This tells us that people share an appreciation of how special Scotland's seas are. Not only that, it says that they want to conserve what makes them special for the benefit of current and future generations."

To support the MPA consultation SNH produced a series of site-specific documents for each MPA. The organisation will now finalise these to reflect the changes it recommends and to support decisions by Scottish Ministers on which sites to designate as Nature Conservation MPAs. SNH will continue to support Marine Scotland and work with sea users to develop management for the sites.

Notes to editors

Marine Scotland's MPA consultation analysis report: www.scotland.gov.uk/Topics/marine/marine-consultation

SNH advice:



SNH's advice on selected responses to the 2013 Marine Scotland consultation on Nature Conservation Marine Protected Areas (MPAs) can be found at www.snh.gov.uk/mpa-advice.

Two other SNH reports related to Scotland's proposed MPA network are also published today as part of our commitment to make our evidence available to others:

Commissioned Report No. 749: The distribution of maerl and other coarse sediment proposed protected features within the South Arran pMPA - a data review to inform management options

Commissioned Report No. 746: Biological analyses of underwater video from proposed marine protected areas, renewable energy sites and spoil grounds around Scotland

The JNCC advice: www.jncc.gov.uk/scottish-mpa-consultation.

Background and additional information:

To meet international commitments, Scotland is required to create a network of Marine Protected Areas (MPAs) in Scottish waters, under the Marine (Scotland) Act and the UK Marine and Coastal Access Act. The network will protect marine wildlife, habitats and undersea landscapes from the coast to 200 nautical miles offshore. The process is led by Marine Scotland. SNH and JNCC provide information and advice about the marine environment in territorial and offshore waters respectively to Marine Scotland and Ministers so they can decide where MPAs should be. The project also includes Historic Scotland, Marine Scotland Science and the Scottish Environment Protection Agency.

Thirty-three sites around the coast of Scotland are being considered by Ministers, including a number of sites initially proposed by community groups and other organisations. Further work has been undertaken in relation to the possible progression of another four areas (MPA search locations) and these will be the subject separate formal advice to Scottish Ministers later in 2014.

The work to identify suitable sites has drawn from the best available information on the marine environment, and has included an extensive programme of marine surveys and research. The proposals have also been discussed with a wide range of groups with an interest in the marine environment at a series of five stakeholder workshops held at key stages over the last two and a half years. These include representatives of the fishing industry, offshore energy developers, recreational users, environmental organisations and local communities.

A map showing the distribution of the thirty-three possible MPAs that were consulted upon in the summer 2013 is available online at www.snh.gov.uk/docs/A1015346.pdf. The updated boundaries of the possible MPAs are available for download via the SNH Natural Spaces web pages https://gateway.snh.gov.uk/natural-spaces/index.jsp and will be viewable on NMPi www.scotland.gov.uk/Topics/marine/seamanagement/nmpihome/nmpi. Further boundary changes may occur as a result of final decisions prior to designations.

Contact information

Name
Dominic Shann
Job Title
Media Relations Officer
Telephone
01463 725157
Email
dominic.shann@nature.scot

NatureScot is Scotland's nature agency. We work to enhance our natural environment in Scotland and inspire everyone to care more about it. Our priority is a nature-rich future for Scotland and an effective response to the climate emergency. For more information, visit our website at www.nature.scot or follow us on X at https://x.com/NatureScot

’S e NatureScot buidheann nàdair na h-Alba. Bidh sinn a’ neartachadh àrainneachd na h-Alba agus a’ brosnachadh dhaoine gu barrachd suim a chur ann an nàdar. Tha e mar phrìomhachas againn gum bi nàdar na h-Alba beairteach agus gun dèilig sinn gu h-èifeachdach le èiginn na gnàth-shìde. Tha an tuilleadh fiosrachaidh aig www.nature.scot no air X aig https://x.com/NatureScot